I count Religion but a childish Toy,
And hold there is no sinne but Ignorance.
Thus begins The Jew of Malta, with a Prologue from none other than Machiavelli. And immediately the audience has a sense of Might over Right.
Many will talke of Title to a Crowne:
What right had Caesar to the Empery?
Might first made Kings, and Lawes were then most sure
When like the Dracos they were writ in blood. – Prologue, 18-21
I wonder how English audiences at the turn of the 17th century felt about Machiavelli. A land mired in the entanglement of Church and State, Queen Elizabeth as Supreme Governor of the Church of England, surely their moral compass remained steadfast and true – that Right resolutely wins over Might. How, then, can one condemn The Jew of Malta as anti-semitic rather than as a protest against the hypocrisy of the Church’s political rule? I digress…for now.
Because popular sentiment toward Jews during Marlowe’s time remained generally hostile, seen as Christ-killers and usurors who rarely succumbed to conversion pressure, he had little trouble in designing Barabas to play to popular prejudices. For those in the audience, Barabas embodies a stereotype and presents an easy target for their hatred. Granted, Barabas’ behavior does very little to disuade those prejudices. When he embarks on his revenge against the Maltese governor, the audience likely shakes their heads in dismay while uttering under their breath, “We were right all along.” Marlowe’s Barabas does not challenge the pervading bigotry within his society. Instead, one might argue that Marlowe intensifies this hatred. After all, Barabas was the one pardoned during the Passover custom instead of Jesus. This audience likely wants to watch him burn.
But why the Machiavellian prologue?
And, oh, how Barabas has his revenge. Marlowe endows him with such cunning; the great deceiver and manipulator, who preys on the pious Christian’s greedy, hypocritical, and proud weaknesses to enact his murderous plots. The captivating double-crosses and alluring twists truly do keep the play highly engaging.
As Barabas speaks of the Governors offense as a scar borne in an age-old war between Jew and Christian and plots against his daughter for joining an enemy nunnery, audiences can hear two things: a Jew raging against innocent Christians, or a proud man scourged by other men in power. Marlowe could have told the same story with inverted roles for Jew and Christian. Audiences of his day would have lamented another St. Barnabas; completely justified in his actions against the powerful heathens under which he toiled. His vast wealth would have been a blessing from God for his piety. His actions against his daughter would have been a sign of his intense adherence to his faith. His plot against the governor’s son and his friend aided by the angels.
But Machiavelli…
The Christian establishment cites their faith to justify their immoral actions. After taking Barabas’ wealth to pay tribute to the Turkish government, they say, “If thou rely upon thy righteousnesse, / Be patient and thy riches will increase. / Excesse of wealth is cause of covetousnesse: / And covetousnesse, oh ’tis a monstrous sinne.” (Governor, I.ii, 121-124) Does not the sin of covetousness apply to the Governor when he takes Barabas’ money? Oh, then decides to fight the Turks rather than pay them and keeps Barabas’ money anyway. Also, “If your first curse fall heavy on thy head, / And make thee poore and scorn’d of all the world, / ‘Tis not our fault, but thy inherent sinne.” (I Knight, I.ii, 107-109). So then Barabas must have been righteous to accrue such wealth before the governor took it. And, “Honor is bought with bloud and not with gold.” (Governor, II.ii, 56) So we should excuse Barabas, then. Alas, no, Barabas does great evil. But he does not do so as a hypocrite hiding his misbegotten anger over Jew’s not remaining in their poverty-stricken, cursed place.
In the Prologue, Machiavelli encourages audiences to judge Barabas by his philosophy when, in truth, Marlowe instead shows audiences how they already judge their Supreme Governor of the Church of England according to Machiavellian philosophy. But because Machiavelli promotes ammoral action to power rather than a meek and pious path, they must bury this method under hypocritical religious doctrine. While I do not find Barabas a sympathetic character, I think audiences ought to acknowledge how all people of all faiths bend to the worldly pressures of power. But not all people make the same choice in how they respond to that strain. Not a single aggressor in the play embraces morality. Each opponent adopts the Machiavellian methods of their adversary in order to “win”. Greed and pride bind each of them in the same web. And if we truly live in this kind of world, then Machiavelli presents our best options to thrive. But make no mistake. The winner may have the power, but the loser has my sympathy.

Leave a Reply